DriveThruRPG.com
Showing posts with label Conventions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Conventions. Show all posts

Monday, June 17, 2019

Origins 2019 After Action Report

So, another Origins game convention is in the books.  This year, I did three full days--Thursday, Friday, and Saturday--and I had overall a great time.  As I have said before, I think Origins is more or less the perfect size, being definitely big, but not overwhelmingly big as Gencon can be (though, I was surprised to see that four-day badges for Gencon are still available, which suggests that it may not be quite so big this year).

Here are my highlights and thoughts:

1.  How Not to Sponsor RPG Sessions at a Convention:  Last year, I ranted a bit about game companies who sponsor game sessions and then have the GMs not show up, and how bad a look that is for the publisher.  [As it turned out, Kobold Press (the folks who had the GM flake on me last year) turned over the running of sponsored games to a third party entity, Warduke Press, and while I didn't get a chance to play in one of those games, I talked to those folks and I am confident they were on the ball.]  This year, I ran sponsored games for two different companies--Pelgrane Press and another publisher that shall remain nameless (so as not to, as the kids say, put them on blast).  This is my fifth con (between Gencon and Origins) that I have run things for Pelgrane, and every single time it is a joy.  Running games for the other publisher was, um, less of a joy.

From my point of view, if you agree to GM games on behalf of a publisher (especially a medium or smaller publisher), part of your job is to make the game, and thus the publisher, look good.  I want to try to sell people on your games.  But the publisher needs to put the GM in the position to make that happen.  And the #1 way to make that happen is to provide high-quality, finished materials for the GM to run.  Instead, I got a half-finished draft of an adventure.  And when I say "unfinished," I mean it was unplayable strictly as written, because there were no stats for the antagonist in the last encounter.  And when I say "no stats," I don't mean there were no stats printed in the adventure, thus requiring the GM to hunt down the relevant stats from various published books (though, that, too); I mean the stats for that antagonist are not printed anywhere.  Either the GM has to come up with the stats on his or her own, or (as I did) you have to cut the last encounter.   

And, to be clear, I got the adventure with a cover email saying "[the product line manager] wants you to run this at Origins," so this was what they wanted put out there.  I suppose you might say "well, you got the adventure the 1st of May; this wouldn't have been as much of a problem if you looked at it earlier than the week before the con."  And, true, but (1) I was busy; and (2) at the end of the day I am a volunteer.  Don't make me do all of this free labor to get your materials in a position that I can use them.  And if your adventure is not ready for prime-time, don't send it to me to run in public.  Help me help you.

By contrast, Pelgrane has a set of publish-quality adventures, written by their top authors in a publish-ready format, strictly for use at conventions.  I also ran an adventure for a game that is in playtest that was at a far higher level polish and completeness than what I got from the other publisher.  This not only makes it much, much easier to run and a much, much more enjoyable experience, but it makes me want to run more things for Pelgrane so I can promote more of their games.  I split my GM time two and two, and I wish I had just run four games for Pelgrane.

Be like Pelgrane, publishers.  Do right by your GMs that volunteer to promote your stuff.

2.  Gumshoe:  Speaking of Pelgrane, I ran an adventure for Trail of Cthulhu and the playtest adventure for the forthcoming Swords of the Serpentine.  Both went well, especially the Swords of Serpentine adventure.  I'm going to do a series on the Gumshoe games, including Swords of the Serpentine, so more on this in a bit.

3.  Starfinder:  I played two Starfinder Society games, and had fun with both of them.  Whatever you want to say about organized play in general and Paizo's version of organized play specifically, they really do a good job of showing off the strengths of the game.  The setting of Starfinder is fun and light-hearted while still having stakes and tension--I've used this analogy before, but it has that Guardians of the Galaxy magic.  So, for example, the first scenario I played involved being on a game show run by undead, and the second one involved a massive invasion of an enemy force, and both of them felt like they belonged in the same world without contradiction.  And the Starfinder scenarios, while not usually breaking any sort of new ground from a design perspective, are consistently solid.  Plus, I have found that they do a good job of making sure the GMs are prepared to provide a good experience at the table.

Saturday night was "the special"--a forty or so table extravaganza where the results of your table affect the things going on with the other table.  There are a series of discrete encounters that the table gets to select from, and after a certain number of groups complete a particular encounter, it is closed for other tables and new encounters are unlocked.  It's chaotic, combat-heavy, and a bit disjointed, but fun--I wouldn't necessarily want to do this every week, but as a once-a-year thing, it's something different and enjoyable.  Also, shout-out to the Starfinder Society folks, including many from the local area--it looked like an enormous undertaking to put this on, and they did a great job.

4.  Pathfinder 2nd Edition:  I was hoping that the two hour demo game I played would be using the final, forthcoming 2nd Edition rules.  It wasn't--it was basically the last version of the playtest.  That was an odd choice, and if I had known that was the deal I probably wouldn't have done it, as I have already messed around with the playtest.

As far as the game itself, I worry that they are going to caught between worlds, and between audiences.  It certainly seems like they have smoothed and streamlined the game as compared to 1st Edition, making it appealing for someone like me who finds 1st Edition too slow, too complicated,  and with too many options to wade through.  But, I'm not sure it was streamlined and smoothed out enough for me to really want to dive in and/or use it as a replacement for 5e or 13th Age.  And, on the flip side, the complexity and options of 1st Edition that turn me off are the very things that have hooked a big chunk of the Pathfinder community, so the streamlining reduces the thing that draws them to the game.  That seems to be the conclusion in the main from the folks in the local Pathfinder Society around here--they have been pretty clear that they intend to run both 1st and 2nd Edition stuff come August when 2nd Edition launches.  So, whatever the merits of the game as a game, I think it may be a misstep as a consumer product and as a community building exercise.

5.  Overlight:  I try at conventions to find at least one game that I will never play otherwise, and this year it was Overlight from Renegade Game Studios, which I had not heard of until now but had a big presence and appears to be a large company.  Overlight was interesting, and a little bit hard to describe--I think the best short description is "surreal, non-Tolkien fantasy."  For example, I played a talking archaeopteryx--a bird-like flying dinosaur--that are expert scientists and logicians.  The system is tied to colors, which in turn are linked to emotional traits like compassion and wisdom.

I could be reading too much into this, but I got the sense that this game was on some level trying to be a metaphor for being LGBT--the PCs are "skyborn," who are noticeably different from other people at birth and inspire either adulation or fear among others.  So, basically, the X-Men, which is probably why I got the "this is really about being LGBT" vibe.  Plus, the rainbow color thing.  If so, great--the fact I am not sure if this is the designer intent show that the metaphor, if it is there, is applied deftly enough not to bludgeon the players in a way that will take away from game play.

I had fun with Overlight, and I would definitely play again if offered, but I wasn't completely captivated by it.  I flipped through the core book in the dealer's area, and it is a beautiful book with a unique art style, but it was $60, and so I passed.  But it is definitely something that folks should look into.

Monday, June 25, 2018

The State of Fantasy RPGs, Part V--Pathfinder 2nd Edition Playtest

I mentioned in the last post that I played in a two hour Pathfinder 2nd Edition (hereafter, "P2") playtest at Origins, and I wanted to give my thoughts.  But first, I should say that I am, at best, a casual fan and player of Pathfinder 1st edition.  I have played Pathfinder probably a half-a-dozen total times, entirely in the context of Pathfinder Society.  I have never GMed Pathfinder.  I have also never played or GMed D&D 3.5, which is the direct predecessor of Pathfinder.  I recite all of this to say that I really have no emotional commitment to Pathfinder 1st Edition, and so I am approaching P2 mostly as its own game on its own terms.  Similarly, if you are looking for a deep dive into the Golarion lore consequences of making Goblins a core Ancestry (i.e. The Artist Formerly Known as "Race"), then I'm not your guy.

Second, I want to give a shout out to Luke Woods.  He's a local Pathfinder Society GM who happened to be the guy who ran the demo for us (Paizo, as usual, had a big operation, and it was a mix of locals, Society GMs from other places, and Paizo employees).  Because he's a local, I've played in a couple of games he has run, and he's an excellent GM and seems like an excellent dude.  He also spent some time after the game chatting with us about his thoughts on P2 with the perspective of running six two-hour demos in a day.  Whatever you think of organized play, the GMs who run games in those settings put in a ton of hard work in tough GMing conditions and deserve to be cheered, especially the good ones.  So, props to him.

Third, I'm going to focus on overall impressions as opposed to listing every mechanical element.  Paizo has done a series of blog posts about the various changes that is pretty comprehensive that you can go to for the deep dive, so instead I am going to focus on the things that jumped out at me from play.  Plus, we'll have the full playtest document in six weeks or so (which, after playing at Origins, I will be picking up, especially since it will be free), and I got the sense from Luke that some elements were still be worked out, so if you want more detail it makes sense to wait to get the actual product in hand.  This post is more about helping you figure out whether or not you are going to be interested in looking at that product in the first place.

OK, now on to my thoughts:

1.  It's Still Crunchy.  Reading the forums the day that P2 was announced, the #1 concern I saw was that Paizo was going to follow the current zeitgeist and dramatically pare down the volume of rules.  I can confidently tell you that this is not the direction they went with for P2.   It may end up being slightly less crunchy than it predecessor, but it is clearly going to be on the crunchier side of the spectrum for RPGs (especially newer RPGs), and it is clearly going to be crunchier than 5e.  And this makes all the sense in the world--they need to find a way to distinguish themselves from 5e, and "more options, more tactical, more mechanically engaging" is a very sensible way to do that, especially since that's where your fanbase is already located.

As some examples, there are a ton (at least 20, based on my quick count of the reference sheet) different status conditions.  That's a lot, especially for someone who routinely forgets to apply conditions to rolls (which I did in the climax of the demo, but upon reading the Paizo blog, it turns out the condition that I forgot to apply actually would have worn off by the time I forgot to apply it.  So, I accidentally did it right).  The character sheet, for a 1st level character, was two full pages of dense information.  We were using pre-gens, so it was hard to get a sense of character creation, but it certainly seemed like you will have lots of relatively small options that you can mix and match to make the character you want.

My sense is that this, in general terms, is what Pathfinder fans want--if they didn't, they probably would have ditched Pathfinder for 5e.  I'm more on the rules-light end of the spectrum, so P2 might be a bit crunchier than I would prefer.  But the point is that it seems they are not chasing 5e, but instead providing an alternative.  That's a good sign for the overall project, I think.

2.  The Death of the 5 Foot Step.  The biggest take-away I had from combat was there was a lot more movement.  Pathfinder combat (and, IME, 5e when using a grid) tends to be pretty static--the parties maneuver around in the beginning, but then the sides settle into a set battle line and trade blows until it's over.  In the demo, folks were moving around quite a bit even in the later stages of a fight.  Even my Paladin, which I was playing extra-tanky on purpose, was moving around quite a bit.

I think this mobility comes from two things.  First, they ditched the move action/standard action/full-round action taxonomy in favor of three actions per turn that you can use anyway you want, including 3 move actions.  Since you can move up to x3 your movement every turn, you can usually get to any spot that you want on the battlefield.  My experience is that if it takes more than a round to get to a spot, players tend to say "forget it," so being able to get to a spot in a round (even if you can't do anything when you get there) encourages players to get and stay moving.

But the bigger factor is that they made attacks of opportunity a special ability, as opposed to something that everyone can do.  And a relatively rare special ability at that--as far as I could see, none of the monsters we fought could do attacks of opportunity, and I think only Valeros the Fighter could do so among the PCs.  I find that the presence of AofO create a psychological barrier that discourages movement, because the players feel like they have screwed up when they trigger an AofO (I know I do), and so they end up moving less to avoid that screw up.  Taking that away empowers players to flit in and out of melee range.

One class that will definitely be seeing more joy in P2 is the Rogue.  I wasn't playing the Rogue and I didn't have the character sheet in front of me, but it didn't seem like the Rogue's abilities were buffed.  Instead, the freedom of movement allowed the Rogue in our party to more consistently get into position to use those abilities.  My experience with Rogue enthusiasts (*cough* Jason *cough*) is that this is exactly what they are looking for.

3.  Shields and Other Equipment Stuff.  So, shields.  My Paladin had a shield.  Basically, you spend one of your three actions to raise your shield, and it stays raised until your next turn.  In addition to bumping up your AC, your shield absorbs the first melee or missile weapon attack against you.  If the attack does damage equal to or greater the shield's hardness (5, in my case), it gets a "dent"; if it takes damage equal to twice the toughness, it takes two dents (I think).  With two dents, it's broken and no longer effective.

This mechanic is great, particularly because it "felt" good.  The fact you had to spend an action to raise a shield made using your shield was a tactical decision that had real trade-offs (one less attack or one less move action), but it was powerful enough to be worth doing.  But it was also the idea that you were actually doing something to block attacks with your shield, without creating a set of cumbersome parry mechanics.  It felt the way using a shield should feel, something that no previous edition of D&D or its derivatives have done.  Extremely well done.

On the equipment front, it seems like they are leaning into individual mechanics for individual weapons, to make a long sword play differently from a spear which plays differently from a dagger.  For example, if you want to multi-attack, the 2nd attack is normally at -5 and the third at -10.  But, if you have a rapier, it's -4 and -8, respectively.  I think that is going to be done via a "tag" system, where each weapon has one or more tags that carry with them the specific properties.  I really need to dig into the rulebook to have a full sense on this system, but Luke seemed particularly excited about it from what he has seen.

4.  No More "Roll for Initiative".  The most genuinely innovative idea that I saw in the playtest was that they have done away with initiative and the initiative roll.  Instead, during "exploration mode" (i.e. the out-of-combat adventuring period), you roll skill checks based on what you are doing during that mode.  So, if you are just generally looking around, you roll Perception; if you are sneaking around, it's Stealth; if you are follow tracks, it's Tracking (or whatever the tracking skill is), etc.  If you do run into a fight, the result on that roll carries over into the fight as your initiative.

Conceptually, this sounds awesome.  One of the things Luke mentioned, and we saw at least the promise of this in our very straight forward demo adventure, is that it allows for encounters that blur the lines between combat and non-combat.  Once the GM says "roll initiative," there is usually a Pavlovian response from both the players and GM that "it's fight time now."  But here, because there is not that clean break, exploration mode can flow into encounter mode (i.e. the fight) more fluidly.  I predict that this will encourage more role-playing and non-combat solutions.  That's great.

Here, though, I need to see it fully described and fleshed out in the rulebook.  I presume the rule is that initiative is determined by the last skill check you attempted--if you were looking around at the beginning of the travel and then started following some tracks, then your Tracking roll and not your Perception roll would control--but I could see how that could get kind of messy in play.  Also, it seems to me that it has the potential of encouraging players to spam their best skill at all times, no matter how appropriate it is narratively (Rogue player: "I'm moving stealthily." GM: "Uh, you have an audience with the king and you are trying to hide?"  Rogue player:  "Yes, exactly.").  So, I can see a bunch of ways where this basically great idea could really fall apart in play, so I am optimistic but reserving judgment until seeing the rule book.


Bottom line--I am much, much more interested in P2 then I was before Origins.  The full playtest document comes out at Gencon in early August, and then they are going to have a year of a public playtest, with a full set of playtest scenarios (spanning all character levels, and apparently designed to really "stress test" the system) before the final version is released.  After what I saw, I'd like to participate.  I might even be convinced to run it with the right group, which would be my first foray into GMing Pathfinder.  It very well may end up not being something that I'm going to want to play long term, but what I saw makes me very willing to give it a shot.

Sunday, June 24, 2018

My Origins After-Action Report

I have the good fortune of having a big games convention right in my hometown--Origins Game Fair, commonly known simply as "Origins."  I've been going for the last few years since I got back into the hobby.  This year, I ended up going in the evenings on the weekdays plus a full day on Saturday (I wanted to do a full day on Friday, but various work commitments got in the way.  Next year).  With the convention over, I wanted to give my thoughts on the convention and what I played.

1.  The convention itself.  Origins might be the perfect size for a convention.  It is, by all metrics, a big convention--one of the top five every year.  But it is not nearly as big and chaotic as Gencon, which is a couple orders of magnitude bigger.  I've been to Gencon twice, and it is so large as to be kind of exhausting.  Origins is much more manageable, but yet has a wide variety of events and experiences such that you get the "big con" feeling.  In the last two years, it has had a very Wizards of the Coast/5e presence and focus, but Paizo brought out the full show (including the Pathfinder 2nd Edition demo--more on that in a bit and in a subsequent post), as well as a number of small and medium-sized publishers with a presence (not to mention all of the board game and miniatures folks).

The one major problem, and this has been an issue for the last couple of years, is that the registration system is bad and unreliable, leading to a number of system crashes.  I wasn't focused on 5e particularly (I tend to use cons to play things I wouldn't/can't play in other contexts), but those events were weirdly not available to register for when I logged on the first day to register, freezing out lots of people from the D&D Open and other big name events.  Plus, the system apparently doesn't let even the event organizers see how many people are signed up for the event, which prevents people putting on multiple events from organizing themselves more efficiently.

They really need to fix this.  There is no reason why it should be like this.

2.  GMs not showing up.  While I am in complaint mode, I was really excited to play a Midgard event that was (or at least, appeared to be) sponsored by Kobold Press.  Cool, Midgard is awesome, Kobold Press is awesome.  So, 9 am on Saturday rolls around, and no GM.  Turns out, according to the people in the room, that he hadn't been there for any of the prior scheduled sessions as well.

This is extremely uncool, and really screws up people's cons.  If you volunteer to GM, you need to be there.  And if someone can't make it for true emergency reasons, the folks organizing the event need to work to find someone, or at least tell people that the event is cancelled ahead of time.  Kobold Press did not, as far as I could tell, have a presence at Origins, making it hard for them to react when someone didn't show up.  I get that, but I feel like if they are sponsoring events they should have a contact person at the event to be able to respond to situations like this.  Don't make people scramble at the time of the event.

Enough about the event.  On to the games.

3.  Torg: Eternity (GMing 2 4 hour sessions).  This was my GMing turn, running Torg under the auspices of the Ulisses Spiele's (technically I guess, Ulisses North America is the official name) demo team.  The groups were smaller than I was hoping, I think in large measure because of the time slot (4 pm, which is sort of in-between sessions--next year, if UNA wants to run demos, I'm going to push for mornings and evenings only).  But I feel like they went well, especially the second session.

One of the things that came across running Torg in a convention setting is that Torg is an easy system to teach noobs.  Torg is not exactly "rules light," but I think the rules are mostly intuitive, and that makes it easier to pick up on the fly.  My worry with Torg is that the card play would cause too much task loading on new players, but people took to the cards quickly.

Anyway, it was fun.  Torg is great.  Go play more Torg.

4.  Pathfinder 2nd Edition (2 hour demo).  I've got a separate post coming in a bit that goes through my thoughts on the demo.  My basic take is that I am far more interested in Pathfinder 2nd Editon than I was prior to the demo.

5.  Starfinder short adventures (2 1-hour sessions).  This was my biggest surprise.  I signed up for the first of these sessions simply because it was the only thing that looked remotely interesting in the time slot I had after I ran Torg, so expectations were decidedly modest.  I went from minimally interested to slotting in a second session and buying the book.

The critics will say that it is Pathfinder in space, and it is impossible to ignore the family resemblance, which is why I was initially lukewarm on the game.  But two things jumped out at me and, to my surprise, grabbed my attention.  First, while I would have to dig in to see exactly why this is so, it does seem to be simpler and move faster than Pathfinder.  No one will mistake it for Numenera or a PbtA game, but combat moved quickly, there were not 40 skills to juggle, and class abilities were straight forward.

But the big thing was that the setting grabbed me.  It's weird science fantasy, with all sorts of brand new races (I was playing a Kasatha, basically a four-armed, grey skinned Conehead).  The central point of the campaign is a giant space station a la Babylon 5 or Deep Space Nine or the Citadel from Mass Effect.  You have sort-of clerics and sort-of sorcerers and the sort-of monk that I was playing, but also gadget based characters and other sci-fi archetypes.  It's nothing close to hard sci-fi--no one will mistake this for Traveller--but it was interesting and fun and it kind of hooked me.  Honestly, the best comparison I can think of is Guardians of the Galaxy, the RPG.

As I said, I went from no interest to looking around for a Starfinder Society game.  I will probably do a Starfinder review in a week or so.

6.  The Dark Eye (2 hour demo).  The Dark Eye is #1 German fantasy RPG, with a 30+ year history and deep lore.  It's published by the Ulisses Spiele folks.  I own the book and have done a read-through, but had never played until Origins.  My basic take is that there is a reason that national stereotypes exist, as this game is very German.  My character sheet was six pages in length, not including a four page cheat sheet providing the descriptions of special abilities and spells.   The skills systems is completely logical--all tasks engage multiple attributes, and so each skill check consists of three sequential attribute checks, which can be manipulated with skill points, and then any left over skill points determine levels of success.  Each successful attack always a dodge or parry roll to try to avoid the blow.  Many spells seemed to take multiple rounds to cast.  And so on.

Now, the world seems very cool--like Midgard, its inspirations are (surprise, surprise) very German and central European.  And it has been a living campaign world since the 80s, with ongoing events that change things up.  The Ulisses Spiele folks want me to run some demos and I want to help out my crew.  But, I mean, a six page character sheet.  That seems like a big ask for a demo situation.

7.  Numenera 2nd Edition (4 hour session).  Also a sneak peak at a 2nd edition (though, Numenera 2nd edition is supposed to be 100% compatible with 1st edition), also really encouraging.  The new stuff, in the form of three new types (i.e. classes) are an explorer type, a tinkerer type, and a face type, fills out the world and adds new dimensions to play.  That's needed, because my #1 problem with Numenera is that it throws a torrent of weird and unique ideas at players and GMs, but doesn't give them a good sense of what to do with all of that stuff.  It seems like they are leaning into a settlement and base-building dimension to play--all the players are set in a town, and they go out and get stuff to help the town grow and prosper.  I like that, though we only saw glimpses of it in the convention adventure.

The bottom line is that Numenera is a great game--it's a breeze to run in the moment to moment, it's easy and fun to play, and the quality of the material you get from Monte Cook Games is uniformly strong.  Great GM, too (whose name, embarrassingly, I can't remember).

8.  Adventurer's League [5e] (2 hour session).  I have not had good experiences with Adventurers' League. A couple times I have had bad GMs.  This time, I had a great GM, but I felt like the adventure was pretty meh, and my fellow players were pretty meh as well.   I don't know what else to say--people love Adventurers' League, and I'm not suggesting they are making it up, but my experiences have not been good.

9.  War of the Cross [boardgame] (dealer's area demo).  New from the 7th Sea folks.  It's basically Diplomacy, with individual faction powers and changing objectives like Twilight Imperium.  Yes please. They will be Kickstarting soon, and I will be backing.

10.  The Ninth World [boardgame] (dealer's area demo).  I bought this game, which is set in the world of Numenera.  It's similar to those "adventure card games" such as the Pathfinder one, in that you play a character that has abilities, complete quests or gather equipment in the form of cards, etc.  One thing I really liked about this game is that it can be played both in a cooperative mode and in a competitive mode, without radically changing the gameplay involved.  I think it will be accessible to people who are not tabletop RPG players or already engaged with Numenera.  It's also beautiful as a physical artifact.